Really 3.5. Not quite a NY slice and barely warm, but they were busy and had a lot of varieties available by the slice. Garlic knots were solid. Not much indoor seating.

It is clean and gets the job done for take out. I get it. It is a take out pizza place but the employees could be a bit more generous in how they speak with customers instead of treating us like a transaction making it look like we are bothering them. However, the Pizza is great. Perfect ratio of bread to toppings and crust with some crispiness/chewiness in every bite. I prefer the supreme and it is magical.

Picked up some to go as we were staying around the corner at the Arlo. Wasn't too hungry and we only wanted a small pizza. The small is only available in cauliflower crust which seemed odd but whatever. Order the backyard which is veggie heavy. Really tasty and had a great kick to the sauce. Crust was thin and crispy, just how I like it. When I did pickup, they had a great selection of by the slice pizzas. A great way to experiment with other flavors. Would recommend.

Came here for a birthday party and if I'm being honest, I wasn't that excited because the menu is so tiny and I tend to gravitate towards a lower carb chicken option. However, I stepped outside of my comfort zone and ordered the wise guy pizza with Caesar salad. My husband and I loved it! 10/10 and the hot honey on the table made the pizza that much more delicious. The atmosphere is absolutely old Italian mob vibe. The name suits it well. Our server was fantastic! Highly recommend and can't wait to come back!

We were in town for a volleyball tournament and gave Wiseguy's a try...Everyone loved the pizza and the service was great! Will definitely try Wiseguy's again!

What I love about Wiseguys is the unique flavors that you don't find at other D.C. pizza shops. I ordered the paneer tikka (my favorite), along with the Korean chicken and buffalo pizzas. The pizzas are made with high quality ingredients, great flavor and large portions. The staff were super friendly, they have both indoor/outdoor seating and are open later than many other food spots in the area.

I recently popped by for a slice on my way between events on a busy day. Inside is small and made for efficiency - you can tell most people are ordering to go. I was greeted and had my order taken quickly, and was in and out within five minutes with three different types - a buffalo chicken (the best one), nashville hot chicken, and vegan supreme. I love a slice shop that has a lot of variety - all done well - and with several convenient locations around the city.